smith machine uk logo

How the Smith machine guillotine press will wreck your shoulders and put your life at risk

By Lee Thomas
Last Updated on 12th August 2020

The guillotine press was made famous by the Iron Guru, Vince Gironda, who was well-known in the fitness industry for his unconventional training methods.

guillotine on a dark foggy background

He felt that the regular bench was inferior for chest development. So instead, he prescribed a "neck press", in which trainees were instructed to literally bring the bar down to their neck.

Now, this form makes perfect sense for chest development from an anatomical perspective—maximum chest stretch, minimum shoulder involvement. So surely it should take pride of balance in your Smith machine chest workout, right?

Well, there is one problem—the guillotine press is absolute suicide for your rotator cuffs. And oh yeah, it can decapitate you if you're not too careful. So what's not to like?

Smith machine guillotine press exercise details

  • Main muscles: Chest
  • Supporting muscles: Shoulders, triceps
  • Exercise type: Compound
  • Difficulty: Advanced
  • Equipment needed: Smith machine, bench
  • Recommended gear: Wrist wraps, chalk
  • Exercise purpose: Develop a more impressive upper chest

How to do the Smith machine guillotine press

Here's how to do a Smith machine guillotine press (if you dare):

  1. Wheel a bench into the Smith machine.
  2. Lie flat on the bench and set the safety stoppers to chest height or just above.
  3. Ask someone to spot you.
  4. Grab the bar with a wider than shoulder-width grip and flare your elbows out to 90 degrees—pain incoming.
  5. Unrack the bar by rotating your wrists and then lower it towards your collarbone.
  6. Press the weight back up once you feel a deep stretch in your chest.
  7. Look in the mirror and tell yourself that you'll never guillotine press again.
"What's more important to you, your life or your gains?"
Alexander Leonidas
On the Guillotine Press

Smith machine guillotine press mistakes

Actually bringing the bar to your neck

Bodybuilder Working Out Chest With Barbell

Don't be the plonker that actually brings the bar down to his neck.

Instead, lower the bar to your collarbone.

This way, if the worst does happen, then you'll only shatter a clavicle—and not your windpipe.

Plus, do you really think that bringing the bar a few centimetres higher up on your body—to your neck—works your chest more?

I hope you don't. And if you do, you're a muppet.

Listening to "hardcore" bodybuilders

Muscular man listening music during his street workout

"Yeh but that bloke from U-tuuube says that any exercise is dangerous with crap form."

"Big Darren does em' an he's proper massive."

Listen, I don't care what those gormless geeks have to say—everyone's hardcore until they get injured.

Plus, all exercises come with different levels of danger.

When was the last time you heard about someone dying from cable curls?

What's that? Never?

And yet. Every. Single. Bloody. Year, people still die from regular bench presses!

You know as well as I do that the only reason why the Smith machine guillotine press doesn't claim more lives is that it's so unheard of. At least you were smart enough to research the exercise before doing it!

Thinking that you need to guillotine press

Body Builder Putting Weights On Bar In Gym

Fact: the incline bench press has built more upper chests than any other pec exercise in history.

I can cite a disgusting number of cases where lads have died from regular bench presses. Now, just imagine how many more deaths we'd have if everyone stared bringing the bar to their necks!

Some bloke got his throat crushed by a 220lb loaded barbell and died [1].

A 15-year old boy died after getting his neck trapped under a 98kg bar. [2]

Another poor fella dropped 50kg on his chest while using a Smith machine! [3]

Sadly, Smith machines lure people into a false sense of security. You must ALWAYS set the safety catches before you load the bar.

And DO NOT EVER just lie under the bar without gripping it. You have a duty to control that bar like you have a duty to protect your children. Your life is too important to perish at the hands of a gym machine or barbell.

Smith machine guillotine press muscles worked

Chest

The Smith machine guillotine press activates more chest muscle fibres than a regular bench press because it places the pecs under an extreme stretch. However, as you'll discover in just a second, muscle activation and actual muscle growth are two very different things.

Front delts

The guillotine press places your front delts in a very weak position. As such, they're hardly active during the exercise.

Triceps

Your triceps are less active during a guillotine press than in a regular bench press simply because your chest is taking more of the load.

Smith machine guillotine press benefits

Higher chest activation

A black man with a muscular body

A grand total of one study shows that guillotine presses activate more chest muscle fibres than regular bench presses [4].

And get this, muscle activation doesn't even equate to real muscle growth. It's just a vague estimate that gives us an idea of what exercises could work in theory.

For example, if I squeeze my chest as hard as possible, I bet my muscle activation levels would be off the bloody chart.

But would I build any size by just squeezing my chest?

Absolutely not.

The guillotine press works the same way. Just because it registers a high EMG reading doesn't mean that it's better for muscle growth than the likes of incline or reverse-grip bench presses.

"If you were to tweak something mid-rep or underestimate your strength with a certain weight, having that bar directly in line with your throat is nothing short of a death wish."
Sean Nalewanyj
Fitness Coach & Writer

Smith machine guillotine press alternatives

Smith machine bench press

strong man performing the flat bench press

The Smith machine flat bench press is a great alternative to the guillotine press because it enables you to overload your chest with more weight. Plus, if you use the proper form, then it's much easier on your shoulders, too.

Smith machine incline press

Young woman lifting a barbell with help from her personal trainer

Performing the Smith machine incline bench press is a brilliant way to build a bigger upper chest safely. And, since there's no need to waste energy stabilising the bar, you can often see faster gains than with the barbell version. Overall, it's an excellent Smith machine neck press alternative.

Smith machine reverse grip bench press

muscular man suffering from shoulder pain against black background

Since the free weight version of this exercise is a bit risky due to the unorthodox underhand grip, which most people aren't accustomed to using, it's a smart idea to always perform the reverse grip bench press on the Smith machine. It's much safer than the Smith machine guillotine press, too.

Oh, and if there's EVER an article of mine that you share, please let it be this one.

I know it sounds dramatic. But learning the truth about guillotine presses could literally mean the difference between life and death for another human being—one who's just trying to better themselves like we all are.

Thanks for reading. And I hope that you learned a thing or two about this deadly exercise.

Lee Thomas
Ey Up! I'm Lee, a Leeds-based strength and conditioning coach who's been helping serious trainees achieve their physical potential for the past 20 years. In my time, I've been a competitive physique athlete and a national powerlifter. I hope you enjoy my exercise guides.
At Smith Machine UK, we create in-depth tests of the latest and greatest gym equipment on the British market so that you can create your dream home gym.
Amazon Associates Disclaimer
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
© Copyright 2014-2020 - Smith Machine UK - All Rights Reserved
hello world!
chevron-upmenu-circlecross-circle linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram